Who said that the Quran's Hajj is religious tourism?
With an open mind, let's let the Quran describe its Hajj for 'mankind' -- not just for 'muslims'.

In this video on Al Moses PhD- Quran Student YouTube Channel, the Author presents his analysis on Hajj where he tackles the following important questions:

Who is the Hajj for?

What is the Purpose of the Hajj?

What the Quran says about the Hajj?

What is the its benefits? Is it just Religious Tourism?

What is the Hajj that appear in the kalam of Allah, the Quran?

Summary

00:00:00 In this section, the speaker discusses the Hajj of Islam and its simplicity. According to the Quran and Islam, Hajj was intended for people, being a religious duty. However, there are questions that arise when the Quranic Hajj is compared with what is seen in the world today. The speaker discusses four fundamental questions about the Islamic Hajj and its purpose, including its definition, the benefits, and legality. One question is about the Quranic Hajj and its instruction, which clearly states that the Hajj is not about hitting stones with stones, going around a stone building seven times, nor just for Muslims but for the entire humanity. The speaker asks who added to such a simple command and who made the declaration that the Hajj should be performed in this manner. The speaker argues that one should use the Quran as the criterion when evaluating such practices, and questions arise when comparing the Quranic Hajj with modern practices, which can seem confusing and different. The speaker mentions that one Ayah from the Quran will be examined in detail to justify practices that may seem controversial in Islam. The Ayah in question, chapter 2 Ayah 196, is about completing the Hajj and Umrah for Allah in accordance with Islamic regulations. However, they acknowledge that some practices may seem different, and there are controversy about the additional conditions added by different social and cultural behaviors. Lastly, the speaker shares a warning to their audience, stating that the traditional translation may not have adequately captured the essence of the Quranic Hajj and its significance in the Islamic faith. Therefore, it's crucial to understand the Quran properly and embrace the spirit of simplicity in the Hajj as it was intended by the Prophet of Islam.

00:05:00 In this section, the speaker raises a series of questions about the meaning and significance of Quranic verses related to the Hajj pilgrimage. These questions touch on various aspects of the Hajj, including its purpose, its benefits, the requirements for participation, and the implications of the verses for men and women, the sick, and those who cannot perform the rituals with perfect precision. The speaker then proceeds to analyze and interpret the verses in an attempt to clarify the nature of the Hajj as described in Islam. Ultimately, he contends that the Hajj is a universal practice meant for all of humanity, regardless of faith, and that the verses offer guidance for those seeking to perform the pilgrimage in accordance with Islamic law and tradition.

00:10:00 In this section of the transcript, the speaker discusses the significance of the Hajj pilgrimage. According to the speaker, Hajj is a gathering for discussions and is not about hitting stone pillars or going around a cube. It is a platform for Humanity to witness benefits, acquire knowledge, and experience reap for themselves. The speaker emphasizes that the Hajj is not limited to Muslims and it is for people of authority, Regal, who can have power with authority.

00:15:00 In this section of the Hajj, the host of the YouTube video is discussing the importance of understanding the true meaning of Hajj and clarifying that it is not a ritual or a religious obligation for Muslims only. They also mention that Hajj is done for the benefit of humanity and serves to strengthen the community. The speaker highlights the use of terms such as umrah, Hadi, and previously mentioned issues, and explains that Hajj is not separated from other Islamic practices.

00:20:00 In this section, the speaker shifts their focus from the discussion of guilt and repentance to the concept of sacrifice. They pose the question of the benefits that result from the sacrifice of animals, particularly those performed during the Hajj pilgrimage. The speaker acknowledges that this is a highly debated subject and suggests that the meaningfulness of sacrifice should not be viewed solely from a practical perspective. Instead, the power of spiritual guidance is emphasized as a fundamental concept for understanding the significance of Hajj. The speaker advocates for a broader and more metaphorical interpretation of the term "sacrifice," as a means of removing certain concepts or ideas from our lives in order to move towards spiritual enlightenment. The speaker concludes that Allah's intention is not to emphasize physical sacrifice or body parts, but rather the removal of the nafs, or soul, from being trapped by materialistic desires and impediments.

00:25:00 In this particular section of the Quran, the word "Siam" is being discussed. The speaker, a Muslim, believes that the best way to understand literature, including the Quran, is to see how the author uses words consistently in their work. "Siam" is a term mentioned in a verse of the Quran that uses the word consistently in the context of abstinence or self-restraint, not just for the purpose of fasting during the Hajj pilgrimage. The speaker provides an example of how the word "Siam" is used in a verse, explaining that it refers to both physical and metaphorical abstinence, not just the act of fasting during Hajj. The speaker emphasizes that much of what is often misunderstood in the Quran is due to people taking a simplistic approach and ignoring the deeper meaning behind certain terms. By studying the Quran in a more nuanced way, individuals can gain a better understanding of the text and the concepts it represents.

00:30:00 In this section, the transcript discusses the term "imaam" from the Ayah Al-Falaq, referring to a person who leads the community in prayers and serves as a source of guidance and help for Muslims. The speaker points out that the Quran primarily focuses on spiritual matters and does not differentiate between men and women, making it irrelevant to any secular concept like "hajj". The term "Ashara" refers to the ten promised paradise for Muslims who perform six religious duties, but the actual collection of people is abstract, referring to a group of people, objects, or types of things set by Allah. The terms "al-Quran" and "al-Masjid" refer to the house of worship and a place where Allah's rules are executed, respectively, but do not mention any specific place. The speaker ends the section by asking the question if people are really saying that after Allah gave them all the instructions, the ones that don't follow them properly will be punished harshly, reducing Allah down to a strict task-master.

00:35:00 In this section, the speaker is emphasizing that Hajj is not about stoning pillars or going around a cube, but rather it is a program for Allah to provide guidance and benefits for humanity. If someone is sick or mentally unavailable and cannot participate in the Hajj, they are expected to practice discipline, leave or agree to ratify the agenda, or cleanse their mental state in order to participate in the beneficial Gathering. The speaker then mentions that the Hajj system should not be harmful and it should be mindful of Allah's system, harsh in recompense. The speaker then indicates that the Hajj gathering is for discussing issues and making decisions such as climate change, gun control, international politics, etc. and it is to provide a forum for these matters to be discussed and decisions to be made. The speaker mentions that those who enter the baitul illah will be in peace, regardless of the number of people stampedes.

00:40:00 In this section, the speaker discusses the debate surrounding the definition of Hajj, one of the five pillars of Islam, which is to travel to Mecca and perform various rituals around the Kaaba, a cuboidal building at its center. The speaker argues that there is no agreement on the definition of Hajj within the Islamic community, and that the majority of traditional translations say something completely different. The speaker also emphasizes that Muslims have the responsibility to follow the Quran and not to rely solely on the opinions of men, regardless of their credibility or appearance. Additionally, the speaker advises that Muslims should come to their own understanding of Islam and make informed decisions, rather than blindly following someone else's teachings.

00:45:00 In this section of the YouTube video, the speaker is emphasizing the importance of having one's own relationship with the Quran and being humble, honest, and sincere. They encourage the audience to keep learning and improving their understanding of Islam. The speaker also highlights the importance of being independent in one's search for knowledge and not just following traditional sources. They quote a verse from the Quran about those who listen to the word of Allah and follow its best guidance being those whom Allah has guided and who possess intellect. Overall, the speaker wants to encourage the audience to strive to be part of the group of people who have a deep connection with Islam through their own understanding of the Quran and their own relationship with Allah.

Summary via Summarize.tech

Content Credit: Al Moses PhD - Quran Student YouTube Channel